How far behind would we be in physics and astronomy if Stephen Hawking never lived?

I don’t want to sound disrespectful to a great physicist and someone who lived against the odds and had a very successful career as a physicist and populariser of science.

However, for perspective, over my career in physics, I never encountered any work by Stephen Hawking, even though I studied and worked in quantum physics related areas.

In contrast, one cannot study physics and not encounter the myriad contributions of Einstein littered throughout many different fields outside of relativity theory. Although that’s hardly a fair comparison.

If I were to compare to say Feynman, then I would say that Hawking’s contribution is less well known, because most students at least learn about Feynman’s path integral formulation of quantum mechanics and Feynman diagrams.


РЕКЛАМА


Another great was John Wheeler. Once more, Wheeler seems to pop up throughout quantum mechanics, quantum information, electrodynamics and cosmology. I would rate Wheeler’s influence on physics as significant. Wheeler had so many unique and interesting ideas.

In fairness, I never studied astrophysics, where Hawking may be mentioned. I did study general relativity, but the course never included any of Hawking’s work on black holes.

Overall, I’d rate Hawking as an important scientist who also popularised physics and whose voice and opinions were heard around the world. He had the opportunity to speak out on matters and have people listen to him. His credentials as a physicist were impressive, but not so much that he overshadowed his contemporaries. He made many important contributions to the interaction of quantum mechanics and general relativity and got to name the as yet untested phenomenon of Hawking radiation. He also wrote a best selling book on the nature of time. By any measure he had a stellar career. The fact that he achieved all of that while being profoundly disabled is quite frankly phenomenal!

RIP Stephen Hawking.


Эта информация была изначально размещена на Quora. Нажмите здесь, чтобы перейти к оригинальному посту.

Do you think Stephen Hawking was a genius? Did you read any of his works?

#Science #Society #Quora

РЕКЛАМА

Что вы думаете по этому поводу?
19 Comments
billyboy915
This is a terrible article, filled with personal opinions posited by someone who, rather than dealing with Hawking's contributions, would diminish him to a degree. He readily admits he did not explore much of what would be considered Hawking's forte, so why should his opinion matter? He never answers his own question about how far behind we'd be without Hawking. He is a nobody, more intent on slaying a giant to make himself appear as brilliant. He failed.
19
02.04.2019 11:47
Ian Swindale
I've read 3 of Hawking's books and whilst not all the contents are readily understood by someone like myself who never took physics, he clearly spread a knowledge and understanding of physics and cosmology as no-one else has done. Others may be more well-known within the physics community but we never hear about them. I think the writer's discussion of what Hawking did , etc is unfair to Hawking and also shows a double picture of him - However, for perspective, over my career in physics, I never encountered any work by Stephen Hawking, even though I studied and worked in quantum physics related areas." and the final paragraph of the article. A rather churlish article in my view.
15
24.08.2018 05:19
Brendan Brannigan
Very misleading header.
8
20.08.2018 04:38
Rajeev Beohar
Deserves a knighthood I think for his brilliance and courage
1
22.03.2025 09:32
Vimala Padmaraj
I AM NOT A SCIENCE STUDENT BY ANY MEANS; MORE INTO ENGLISH LITERATURE. MY ONLY KNOWLEDGE OF STEPHEN HAWKING IS FROM THE TV SERIES "THE BIG BANG THEORY".
0
26.06.2023 11:48
bonniecardona
Amazing man with a great sense of humour
2
18.12.2021 04:38
Rajeev Beohar
Great minds are not judged fairly in their own times but are only enlightened by posterity....
3
13.04.2020 12:43
Donna Smith
Never read any of his books ..and don't want to..
1
20.12.2019 02:20
ninakamwene
I respect all scientists and have read Hawking's Theory of Time. What he achieved with so much physical impediment is admirable. Einstein is on his own category, simply super genius. We need to honor all these brainiacs.
4
04.09.2019 09:51
hector tubens
Interesting information.
1
18.08.2019 09:46
marybethmartin
Sounds like sour grapes!! Too bad.
4
10.05.2019 02:48
Dani Smith
John Stepp, so why did you read the article?
0
05.04.2019 02:24
Don Racette
Chubb Michaub Are you humming a song to your wife??
3
28.02.2019 05:05
Gayle Rutledge Arnold
I don't believe that you can say that we would be any farther along with or further behind without this great man, as you don't know if he had not been around who would have stepped up and possibly explored and determine the same things that he did. Rest in peace!
2
24.08.2018 12:01
Jun Soriao
The man that just passed away metamorphosed from a healthy and quick-witted individual to become an eminent scientist of note. The Lucasian chair, once held by Isaac Newton, could not have been bestowed upon him had not for his brilliant mind. His books (God Made the Integers and Standing on the Shoulder of Giants) are a reservoir of knowledge that adorn my private library. Such are worth reading because the tomes exposes my limitations in the field of mathematics.
1
21.08.2018 06:26
JP Dayes
We the people for the people!
5
21.08.2018 05:31

РЕКЛАМА

Выбор редакции

Интересные факты

Мама превращает полезную пищу в героев мультфильмов, чтобы порадовать сына! 12.09.2016

Все знают, насколько дети бывают избирательны в еде. Любящие родители придумывают различные способы заставить детей питаться правильно, но то, что придумала эта мама - просто гениально!

Читать далее

#Культура #Общество

РЕКЛАМА